How to Get 92% Newsletter Sponsor Renewal Rates (Even With a Small List)

In partnership with

THIS WEEK’S LESSON

Want sponsors to fight over your newsletter? Here's my playbook for building a 92%+ renewal rate

The hardest part about landing newsletter sponsors isn't the pitch.

It's not your subscriber count either (though my 3,790 engaged readers help).

It's building an audience that actually gives a damn about what you have to say.

I've learned this firsthand. My education leadership podcast now ranks in the top 0.5% globally with 1.69M IAB downloads. The secret? A crystal-clear point of view that attracts the right sponsors and repels the wrong ones.

That’s how I sold my first sponsorship in the first year of my podcast with barely any listeners at all …

What you need to understand is this: (if you have a podcast, vlog, or newsletter) you are a media company, and …

The traditional sponsorship playbook is broken

Most creators chase raw numbers: subscribers, downloads, impressions. They'll take any sponsor with a pulse and a checkbook.

I flipped the script. My "Ruckus Makers" brand focuses on education leaders who want to "Do School Different." This means shifting FROM old, broken ways of teaching TO new, creative approaches.

The results?

• 46.55% email open rate (education industry average: 37.35%)

• 92%+ renewal rates from sponsors like Harvard and others.

• One sponsor, IXL, has continually increased their investment for over a year because of the ROI they’re getting

Why it works

Sponsors aren't buying ads. They're buying access to a movement.

"Most of my inbound organic leads come from Danny's show," says Mitch Weathers, CEO of Organized Binder, who's renewed 97% of the time.

My pitch is simple:

• 13 episodes = 11,700-27,157 listens (first 30 days)

• Website bonus impressions

• Starting at $7.5K per quarter

But the real value? Speaking directly to education innovators every single week.

My playbook for attracting premium sponsors:

1. Build an engaged audience first

• Consistent content: 3x a week

• Clear point of view

• No random sponsorships

2. Package strategically

• Bundle podcast ads with newsletter placements

• Offer quarterly commitments (not single episodes)

• Include bonus impressions to sweeten the deal

3. Focus on retention

• Simple onboarding process

• Clear deliverables

• Proven results that keep sponsors coming back

The bottom line: You don't need millions of subscribers. You need the right subscribers who trust your point of view.